The Case for a Single-Vendor Talent Strategy

When it comes to hiring, speed, quality, and experience are everything. For high-growth companies, the pressure to fill roles quickly is higher than it’s ever been. According to HRLineup, 76% of employers report talent shortages in 2025, an all-time high. As a talent solutions architect at Insight Global’s professional services division, I’ve seen the competition for top talent at companies of all sizes more intense and urgent than ever before. This intensity often leads organizations to hedge their talent acquisition spending and adopt a multi-vendor staffing model.

In theory, employing multiple vendors for contingent staffing can appear advantageous. Diversifying recruitment sources should lead to a broader talent pool, quicker hiring times, and cost containment. This concept hinges on the idea that more vendors means more quality candidates, and theoretically, a better chance to find the perfect fit for each role.

After all, “competition breeds excellence,” doesn’t it?

The truth is this approach often delivers the opposite. When multiple staffing vendors are engaged simultaneously, the hiring process becomes fragmented. There’s no centralization of data, no unified strategy, and no consistent candidate experience. Each vendor operates in a silo, often positioning the client’s brand differently and sometimes poorly. This inconsistency can damage employer branding and erode trust in the hiring process.

Moreover, the lack of visibility across vendors makes it difficult to track performance, measure ROI, or plan strategically. When using multiple vendors, hiring is often reactive, not proactive. Instead of building a pipeline of talent aligned to future needs, companies are constantly playing catch-up, filling roles as they open, rather than anticipating demand. There becomes a “race to the bottom” in cost, which negatively impacts quality. Poor quality then leads to lower productivity and drag on the business achieving their core priorities.

This model may deliver volume, but it struggles to provide quality and rarely delivers value.

But of course, there’s a better way.

Adopting a Single Vendor Talent Strategy

As organizations mature and scale, many are recognizing that the answer isn’t more vendors—it’s the right partner.

Transitioning from a fragmented, transactional hiring model to a centralized, strategic talent partnership can be transformative for a business. When companies consolidate their staffing efforts under a single, trusted partner, they unlock a host of benefits that directly impact business performance:

• Faster time-to-productivity: Tailored onboarding accelerates ramp-up time, boosting productivity, and reducing turnover.
• Enhanced visibility: A unified approach enables real-time insights into hiring metrics, pipeline health, and performance empowering better, faster decision-making.
• Improved ROI: Streamlined processes accelerate every stage of hiring, from submittal to interview to offer, resulting in measurable improvements in efficiency and cost-effectiveness.
• Talent lifecycle optimization: From sourcing to onboarding to engagement, a holistic strategy ensures a seamless experience that supports long-term success.
• Reduced administrative burden: A single point of contact simplifies governance, compliance, and communication, freeing up internal teams to focus on strategic priorities.
• Consistent brand experience: Every candidate interaction reflects the organization’s values, culture, and mission, thus strengthening employer brand and candidate trust.

These aren’t just theoretical benefits. These are real, measurable outcomes that fuel business growth. But achieving them requires more than just good intentions; it demands a shift in strategy.

For example, when we’ve worked with clients to become a single vendor for their contingent needs, we’ve seen impacts on their time to productivity, retention, and more.

• Fortune 500 Agriculture Company: Accelerated time-to-productivity by 20% through a customized onboarding experience tailored to the client’s unique operational landscape.
• Fortune 500 Logistics Company: Boosted consultant retention from 70% to 96% by implementing targeted engagement strategies that fostered stronger alignment and satisfaction.
• Global Pharmaceutical Leader: Elevated Net Promoter Score (NPS) from 33 to 75 (on a scale of -100 to 100) by combining personalized onboarding with strategic consultant engagement, driving measurable improvements in experience and loyalty.

When To Shift to A Single-Vendor Strategy

If your organization is experiencing any of the following, it may be time to consider a new approach:

• You’re hiring annually and struggling to keep up.
• You’re managing multiple vendors with inconsistent results.
• You lack visibility into hiring performance and ROI.
• You need to improve onboarding, retention, or candidate experience.
• You’re scaling fast and need a partner who can grow with you.

Insight Global’s talent services were built for this moment. It’s a centralized, strategic, and scalable solution designed to help high-growth companies move from reactive hiring to proactive talent strategy. If you’re ready to go from chaos to clarity, it may be time to explore what we can do for you. Start growing with Insight Global by connecting with us today. 

Chat with Insight global’s talent experts